Pluribus - Season 1 (2025) TV Series Review: Vince Gilligan and Rhea Seehorn Return with a Masterfully Unsettling Sci-Fi Satire

There is a specific weight that comes with being the follow-up to two of the most celebrated dramas in television history. For Vince Gilligan, the mastermind behind the Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul universe, the expectations for his next move were not just high; they were astronomical. With the arrival of Pluribus Season 1 on Apple TV+, Gilligan has finally stepped away from the meth labs and legal loopholes of Albuquerque to return to his genre roots. While he cut his teeth on The X-Files, this new nine-episode endeavor feels like something entirely different: a high-concept, science fiction psychological thriller that acts as a spiritual successor to the unsettling morality plays of The Twilight Zone.

Premiering on November 7, 2025, and produced for Apple TV+, the series reunites Gilligan with his Better Call Saul standout, Rhea Seehorn. Seehorn plays Carol Sturka, a successful but deeply cynical author of fantasy romance novels living in Albuquerque. The setup is deceptively simple: an extraterrestrial virus known as "the Joining" sweeps across the globe, transforming humanity into a peaceful, blissfully happy hive mind called "the Others". However, Carol is one of only thirteen people on the planet who are inexplicably immune. While the rest of the world descends into a terrifyingly polite utopia, Carol remains her grumpy, independent self, forced to navigate a world that wants nothing more than for her to "join" the collective joy.

This debut season is a bold statement in the current TV landscape. At a time when many streaming series feel like padded-out movies, Pluribus is a dense, deliberate exploration of what it means to be an individual when the cost of community is the loss of the self. It is a project that feels both massive in scope and intensely personal, anchored by a performance that confirms Seehorn as one of the finest actors of her generation.

Narrative Arc and Pacing: The Slow Burn of a Cozy Apocalypse

The storytelling in Pluribus is a masterclass in what critics often call the "slow-burn," though Gilligan’s version of it never feels stagnant. The season is meticulously plotted, avoiding the "filler" episodes that plague many modern streamers. Instead of the visceral horror of a typical zombie outbreak, the "Joining" creates a "cosy apocalypse". We see the world shift not through gore, but through a chilling lack of conflict. In the two-episode premiere, written and directed by Gilligan himself, we witness the immediate aftermath through Carol’s eyes as she returns from a book tour to find a world that has reorganized itself into something unrecognizable and disturbingly gracious.

The pacing is deliberate, spooling out information about the virus and its extraterrestrial origins at a rate that rewards patient viewers. While some might find the narrative's tendency to hold its cards close to its chest a bit frustrating, the mystery only becomes juicier as the episodes progress. The writers—including alumni like Gordon Smith and Alison Tatlock—excel at subverting tropes; they know we expect a survivalist thriller, so they give us a satire about the "philosophical conundrum of goodness".

Throughout the seven episodes provided for review, the themes evolve from simple survival to a deep-seated critique of social conformity. The show asks uncomfortable questions about the value of unhappiness and whether a forced peace is actually just a different kind of prison. There is a recurring sense of "pandemic art" here, as the isolation Carol feels mirrors the collective trauma of recent history, but viewed through a prism that makes the familiar feel entirely alien.

Character Evolution and Performances: A One-Woman Powerhouse

While the premise is the hook, the heart of Pluribus is Rhea Seehorn. Gilligan famously wrote the role of Carol specifically for her, and she rewards that faith with a performance that spans the entire emotional spectrum. Carol is not a typical hero; she is a "good old-fashioned cynic" who refers to her own best-selling work as "mindless crap". Yet, her flaws are what make her the perfect guide through this new world. Seehorn captures the physical toll of Carol’s resistance, showing her "buckling under the weight" of her isolation with eyes that reflect a deep-rooted discontent that predates the alien arrival.

The chemistry between Seehorn and Karolina Wydra, who plays Carol’s "chaperone" Zosia, is a standout element of the season. Zosia is a member of the hive mind, yet there is a "push-and-pull" between them that hints at lingering traces of the old world. Their relationship toes a delicate line between enemies and an odd sort of intimacy, providing the show’s most vulnerable moments.

The supporting cast, though often playing "one person in many bodies," is equally impressive. Miriam Shor as Carol’s partner Helen and guest stars like Samba Schutte and Carlos-Manuel Vesga provide glimpses into how other immune individuals react to the Joining—ranging from hedonism to total withdrawal. However, the show belongs to Seehorn. She carries the emotional core on her shoulders, moving from harrowing tragedy to dry-wit comedy with a grace that makes her lack of an Emmy for Saul feel even more like a historical oversight.

Direction and Production Value: Neon Noir in a Sunny Utopia

Visually, Pluribus is a treat for those who appreciate Gilligan’s signature aesthetic. The return to Albuquerque brings back the wide, panoramic vistas and crisp desert cinematography we’ve come to expect, but with a different color palette. The world of the "Others" is superficially brighter and more cheerful, with a sky that appears almost "too blue" and neighborhoods that blend into a sterile mimicry of perfection.

The direction is consistently sharp, featuring technically stunning feats of choreography and camerawork. There is a "synchronized dance" feel to scenes involving the hive mind that is both impressive and deeply eerie. As the season progresses into the back half, the visual style shifts toward a "noir" influence. Scenes of Carol’s nighttime investigations are soaked in harsh neon lights, providing a gritty contrast to the daytime utopia. This world-building is executed with top-tier editing and unconventional angles that make even mundane locations, like an empty jetliner or a grocery store parking lot, feel heavy with tension.

The production design also leaves plenty for eagle-eyed fans to savor. The inclusion of a "Wayfarer Airlines" plane—the same fictional airline from the Breaking Bad universe—serves as a provocative Easter egg. It suggests a shared universe where this apocalypse might officially close the book on any future Bad sequels, a bold move that adds a layer of lore-heavy intrigue for long-time viewers.

Trailer Pluribus - Season 1 (2025) TV Series

Soundscape and Atmosphere: The Choral Echo of the Many

The sound design and score are essential in building the show’s "creepily cheerful" mood. Breaking Bad composer Dave Porter returns, but he ditches the gritty, industrial sounds of the past for something entirely different. The score is largely choral-based, a brilliant thematic choice that represents the collective voice of the hive mind. These voices create an atmosphere that is simultaneously beautiful and terrifying, mirroring the "psychic glue" that binds the Others together.

Silence is used just as effectively as the music. The quiet moments emphasize Carol’s loneliness and the "unsettling composure" of the people around her. One of the most creative atmospheric touches is a phone number that appears on screen during the first episode, which viewers are encouraged to call for a "treat," further blurring the lines between the show’s world and our own. From the eerie music of the first teaser trailers to the internal soundscape of Carol’s spiraling paranoia, the audio work is as sophisticated as the writing.

Strengths and Weaknesses

What works well:

• Rhea Seehorn delivers a career-defining, powerhouse performance that carries every scene.
• The high-concept premise is a refreshing, satirical take on the "end of the world" that avoids typical zombie clichés.
• Vince Gilligan’s visual direction remains top-tier, with stunning use of the Albuquerque landscape and neon-noir lighting.
• The "synchronized" choreography of the hive mind creates a unique and effective sense of physical unease.
• The thematic depth explores autonomy, community, and the value of "unhappiness" in a way that is both funny and thought-provoking.

What doesn't work:

• The "slow-burn" pacing and the way the show holds its cards so close to its chest might frustrate viewers looking for faster answers.
• Some of the secondary clues, such as the numbers with "Biblical overtones," remain murky and their relevance is unclear by the mid-season point.
• The premise results in a very small pool of distinct characters, which might feel limiting to those who prefer large ensemble dynamics.

Final Verdict: A Tense Sandbox of Human Defiance

Rating: 5/5 stars

Pluribus is, without a doubt, the television event of 2025. It is a series that justifies every bit of the time investment, rewarding viewers who pay close attention with a narrative that is as satisfying as it is strange. It is a show unlike anything else currently on air—a "Black Mirror-style" satire that manages to be hilarious, heartbreaking, and genuinely nerve-shredding all at once.

This series is a must-binge for anyone who appreciates the meticulous world-building of Vince Gilligan or the sheer acting force of Rhea Seehorn. It will particularly resonate with fans of "cerebral" sci-fi like Severance or Invasion of the Body Snatchers enthusiasts. However, those who find deliberate pacing or narrative ambiguity frustrating might find themselves "Breaking Sad" along with the protagonist.

With a second season already guaranteed, Pluribus has the potential to define this decade of television the way Gilligan’s previous works defined the start of the century. It is a masterful return to form that proves its creator is only getting better with age.

Watch or Pass: Watch