It has been nearly a decade since the Four Horsemen last vanished from our screens, leaving behind a legacy of box-office success that arguably outstripped critical acclaim. In an era dominated by cinematic universes and unending IP mining, the arrival of a third installment, Now You See Me: Now You Don’t, might initially feel like a late trick no one asked to see. Yet, under the direction of Ruben Fleischer—stepping in for Jon M. Chu—this 2025 Movie pulls off a surprising feat: it justifies its own existence with a winning blend of nostalgia, fresh energy, and sleek, unapologetic fun.
Reuniting the original cast while introducing a charismatic new generation of illusionists, the film feels less like a desperate cash grab and more like a high-speed Heist Movie reunion. The premise finds our Robin Hood-style magicians targeting a corrupt South African diamond tycoon, played with delicious camp by Rosamund Pike. While it may not convert skeptics who found the previous entries too ridiculous, for fans and casual viewers alike, this is a polished, entertaining escape that knows exactly what it is.
Story and Screenplay
The narrative picks up ten years after the events of Now You See Me 2, with the original Horsemen largely disbanded and out of the public eye. The void has been filled by a scrappy trio of younger magicians—Bosco (Dominic Sessa), June (Ariana Greenblatt), and Charlie (Justice Smith)—who emulate the Horsemen’s ethos of exposing corruption through spectacle. When the groups inevitably collide, recruited by the ever-controlling J. Daniel Atlas (Jesse Eisenberg), they target Veronika Vanderberg (Pike), a diamond heiress using her empire to launder money for warlords.
The screenplay, penned by a committee including Seth Grahame-Smith and Michael Lesslie, abandons the convoluted law enforcement subplots of the previous films to double down on the magician-vs-tycoon dynamic. Structurally, the film moves with the rhythm of a Fast & Furious entry: it prioritizes "family," spectacle, and globe-trotting set pieces over logical coherence.
Is the plot riddled with holes? Absolutely. The narrative logic is flimsy at best, often relying on "it’s magic!" to explain away impossibilities that would break a more grounded drama. However, the film embraces a tone of "knowing goofiness" that makes these flaws easier to forgive. It moves at such a clip, bouncing from a heist in Antwerp to a chase in Abu Dhabi, that the audience rarely has time to question the mechanics before the next illusion begins.
Acting and Characters
One of the film's greatest assets is the palpable chemistry of its ensemble, which feels warmer and more cohesive than in the previous chapters.
The Returning Horsemen: Jesse Eisenberg delivers perhaps his most confident performance as J. Daniel Atlas. Shedding the anxiety-riddled arrogance of his younger years, he steps into a more grounded, commanding leadership role, channeling a bit of Danny Ocean energy. Woody Harrelson remains a delight as the hypnotist Merritt McKinney, bringing his signature laid-back, slightly stoned humor to the mix. Dave Franco returns as Jack Wilder, engaging in impressive card-throwing action sequences, while Isla Fisher makes a welcome return as escapologist Henley Reeves, restoring the original dynamic that was missed in the second film.
The New Blood: The fresh recruits are far more than just plot devices. Dominic Sessa (The Holdovers) is a standout as Bosco LeRoy, proving his star power with a performance that balances "dickish" charm with genuine soul. Justice Smith brings a likable, tech-savvy energy, and Ariana Greenblatt impresses as June, a pickpocket with surprising parkour skills that add a physical dimension to the heist sequences.
The Villain: Rosamund Pike steals every scene she is in as Veronika Vanderberg. Adopting a heightened, "bananas" South African accent, she leans fully into the campy tone of a Bond villain, providing a perfect foil for the team. She is threatening yet entertaining, a "smarmily two-faced" adversary you genuinely want to see taken down.
Direction and Technical Aspects
Director Ruben Fleischer, known for Zombieland, injects the franchise with a kinetic, pop-corn energy. He understands that a movie like this lives or dies by its pacing, and he ensures the momentum never lags.
Visually, the film’s centerpiece is a sequence set in a French chateau turned "magic museum." This set piece features a hall of mirrors, upside-down rooms, and forced-perspective corridors that the characters use to disorient their enemies. It is a creative high point that blends practical set design with visual effects, capturing the playful spirit of the series better than the standard CGI-heavy finales of many blockbusters.
However, the film does suffer from the franchise's habitual over-reliance on CGI to depict "magic." At times, the illusions feel less like sleight of hand and more like digital wizardry, which can undercut the awe of the stunts.
Trailer Now You See Me: Now You Don't (2025)
Music and Atmosphere
Returning composer Brian Tyler provides a propulsive score that complements the film's heist-thriller pacing. The music, combined with slick editing, creates an atmosphere of lighthearted suspense. The tone strikes a careful balance between the "Robin Hood" social commentary—touching on wealth inequality and corruption—and pure, disposable escapism. It acknowledges the darkness of the real world (mentioning war and climate change) only to argue that we need magic and wonder now more than ever.
Strengths and Weaknesses
Strengths:
- Ensemble Chemistry: The cast, both old and new, genuinely seems to be having fun, which is infectious.
- Sessa's Breakout: Dominic Sessa proves he is a movie star in the making, holding his own against seasoned veterans.
- Creative Set Pieces: The "Magic Manor" sequence is a visual treat that plays with perspective and environment brilliantly.
- Rosamund Pike: Her committed, campy performance elevates the generic villain role into something memorable.
- Plot Logic: The story falls apart under even unrivaled scrutiny, with convenient twists and unexplained "magic" hacks.
- Thin Characterization: Despite the charm, the characters remain largely archetypal with little depth below the surface.
- CGI Overload: The reliance on visual effects to sell practical magic tricks continues to be a franchise crutch.
Final Verdict
Rating: 3.5/5 stars
Now You See Me: Now You Don’t is a rare example of a belated sequel that feels energized rather than exhausted. It does not reinvent the wheel—or the deck of cards—but it shuffles the familiar elements of celebrity charisma, glossy heists, and intricate illusions into a winning hand.
While it may not win over critics looking for gritty realism or deep character studies, it is a "blast of pure fun" that outshines many of the year's more self-serious blockbusters. If you are willing to suspend your disbelief and enjoy the ride, this Action-Comedy delivers exactly the kind of old-fashioned Hollywood entertainment that audiences often crave.
Who Should Watch: Fans of Ocean's Eleven or Fast & Furious, admirers of the previous films, and anyone looking for a fun, breezy night at the movies. Who Should Skip: Viewers who demand rigorous plot logic or prefer practical magic to CGI spectacles.
Recommendation: Stream it or See it with a Crowd. The collective "oohs and aahs" of a theater audience enhance the magic trick experience.
 Movie Review: A Sleight-of-Hand Sequel That Recaptures the Magic){kind=link}
0 Comments