It has been over two decades since Zooey Deschanel helped define the modern Christmas classic with her role in Elf, and her return to the holiday season has been a point of high anticipation for genre enthusiasts. Her latest effort, Merv (2025), directed by Jessica Swale and written by the duo of Dane Clark and Linsey Stewart, attempts to capture that same lightning in a bottle by mixing romantic comedy tropes with the undeniable appeal of a depressed dog. Produced by Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, Catchlight Studios, and Lightworkers Media, the film skipped a traditional theatrical run to debut directly on Prime Video on December 10, 2025.
The story follows Anna (Zooey Deschanel) and Russ (Charlie Cox), a formerly happy couple whose lives are still tethered together by their shared ownership of an adorable dog named Merv. Following their breakup, Merv seems to have lost his zest for life, prompting a concerned Russ to take the pup on a rejuvenating getaway to Florida. When Anna shows up unannounced to check on her furry companion, the trio is forced into an awkward, tropical holiday vacation. While the setup promises a breezy exploration of post-breakup dynamics, the film often struggles to find a consistent tone between its broad comedy and its overly sentimental core.
Story and Screenplay: Familiar Beats and Flat Humor
The narrative quality of Merv is perhaps its most significant hurdle. The screenplay by Clark and Stewart operates with a startling lack of subtlety, opting instead to place every emotion and plot point directly on the surface. The central concept of "dog co-parenting" is a relatable modern hook, yet the script fails to dig into the actual complexities of such an arrangement. Instead, it uses Merv’s emotional state as a convenient, often flimsy excuse to force the protagonists into the same physical space. This leads to a story that feels less like a natural progression of characters and more like a series of checkboxes being ticked off for a holiday checklist.
Originality is not the primary goal here, as the film leans heavily into the "second chance at love" trope that defines the Hallmark and Netflix holiday landscape. However, even within those established boundaries, the writing lacks the sharp wit or clever subversion that might set it apart. Many of the attempts at humor feel dated or fall flat, relying on broad physical comedy or puns that rarely land with the intended impact. The themes of healing and reconciliation are handled with a heavy hand, leaving little room for the audience to draw their own conclusions about Anna and Russ’s relationship.
The pacing and rhythm of the film are also problematic. According to production data, the movie clocks in at a staggering 131 minutes. For a romantic comedy with such a straightforward trajectory, this length is almost inexcusable. There are numerous sequences that feel stretched beyond their breaking point, turning what should have been a brisk holiday romp into a slow crawl. The middle act, in particular, suffers from a repetitive cycle of bickering and making up that adds very little to the overall character development or the resolution of the plot.
Acting and Characters: Elevating the Fluff
If there is a saving grace to be found in Merv, it is in the casting of the two leads. Zooey Deschanel and Charlie Cox are both seasoned professionals who understand exactly what kind of movie they are in. They bring a level of commitment and charisma that almost manages to mask the deficiencies of the script. Deschanel retains her trademark quirkiness, though she is forced to play a character who often lacks agency. Anna frequently feels as though she is reacting to the men in her life rather than making her own decisions, which is a disappointing use of Deschanel’s talents.
Charlie Cox, best known for much grittier fare, is surprisingly effective as the well-meaning, slightly overwhelmed Russ. He plays the "dog dad" role with a sincerity that makes his bond with Merv feel genuine. The chemistry between Cox and Deschanel is undeniably the highlight of the film. They have a natural, easygoing rapport that suggests a deep history between their characters, even when the dialogue fails to support it. It is clear they are having a bit of fun together, and those fleeting moments of genuine connection provide the movie’s most heartwarming beats.
The supporting cast is led by Patricia Heaton and David Hunt as Russ’s parents, who provide a fairly standard version of the "meddling but loving" in-laws. Chris Redd appears as a vice principal, attempting to inject some much-needed energy into the comedic subplots, though he too is often hampered by the uninspired writing. Of course, the real star for many will be Merv himself. The dog is appropriately cute and handles his "acting" duties with a soulful gaze that outclasses many of his human counterparts.
Direction and Technical Aspects: Sunshine, Holiday Decor, and a Dragging Clock
Director Jessica Swale, who previously showed a talent for period drama with Summerland, takes a much more conventional approach here. Her vision for Merv is one of bright, saturated colors and festive decor, which fits the sunny Florida setting. The decision to set a Christmas movie in the tropics is a welcome change of pace from the usual snow-drenched landscapes, and the cinematography by the technical team captures the lushness of the location well. However, the visual composition rarely ventures beyond the standard look of a high-budget television movie.
The editing is the primary technical weak point. As mentioned previously, the runtime is a significant issue, and it feels as though a more ruthless edit could have tightened the experience significantly. There is a lack of visual storytelling that might have helped convey the passage of time or the shifting emotions of the characters more efficiently. Instead, the film relies on long, dialogue-heavy scenes that eventually become exhausting. The production design is functional and pleasant, creating a world that feels cozy and safe, which is exactly what the intended audience likely desires.
Trailer Merv (2025)
Music and Atmosphere: Sugar-Coated Holiday Vibes
The score and soundtrack of Merv lean fully into the saccharine nature of the genre. The music is filled with jingling bells and upbeat, acoustic arrangements that signal exactly how the audience is supposed to feel at any given moment. While it is effective at creating a baseline of holiday "comfort," it lacks any distinct personality. The sound design is equally straightforward, with a focus on making every "woof" from Merv and every sunset wave feel as crisp and idealized as possible.
The overall mood and tone are aggressively sentimental. The film is determined to be sweet at all costs, which eventually leads to a sense of emotional hollowness. By refusing to let the characters experience genuine, messy conflict, the eventual resolution feels unearned. The atmosphere is one of pure escapism, but it is the kind of escapism that dissolves the moment the credits roll. It is a cinematic warm blanket that, unfortunately, feels a little too thin to provide much lasting heat.
Strengths and Weaknesses
What works well:
- The Lead Chemistry: Zooey Deschanel and Charlie Cox share a genuine spark that keeps the movie watchable even during its slowest stretches.
- Merv the Dog: The titular pet is undeniably charming and provides the most consistent emotional hook for the audience.
- The Florida Setting: Breaking away from the "White Christmas" aesthetic offers a visually refreshing take on the holiday season.
- Cozy Escapism: For viewers looking for a low-stakes, comforting experience, the film provides exactly that.
What doesn't work:
- Excessive Runtime: At over two hours, the film is far too long for the story it is trying to tell, leading to significant pacing issues.
- Uninspired Script: The dialogue is frequently on the nose, and the attempts at humor are often woefully unfunny.
- Lack of Character Depth: The protagonists feel constrained by the requirements of the genre, preventing any real evolution on screen.
- Overly Saccharine Tone: The film's insistence on being sweet and "Hallmark-ready" strips away any sense of genuine tension or stakes.
Final Verdict: Comfort Food for the Uncritical
Rating: 2.5/5 stars
Merv (2025) is a film that knows exactly who its audience is and is perfectly content to serve them a familiar, if slightly overcooked, meal. It is a production that relies almost entirely on the magnetism of its stars and the cuteness of its animal lead to carry it through a lackluster narrative. While it is heartening to see Zooey Deschanel back in the holiday spirit, one wishes she had been given a vehicle with a bit more bite or a much sharper wit.
Who should watch it? This is a movie designed for those who find comfort in the formulaic nature of cable holiday movies. If you are a fan of the "Lindsay Lohan on Netflix" brand of Christmas cinema or if you simply cannot resist a movie where a dog plays a central role, Merv will likely satisfy your cravings. It is the kind of film that works best when played in the background while decorating the tree or wrapping gifts.
Who might not enjoy it? Viewers looking for a romantic comedy with substance, clever dialogue, or a reasonable runtime should probably look elsewhere. If you find yourself easily frustrated by predictable plot beats and "punny" humor that misses the mark, Merv will likely be a taxing experience. It is a film that stays strictly on the surface, offering little for those who want their holiday stories to have a bit more depth.
In the grand tradition of holiday movies, Merv is a disposable bit of festive fluff. It provides enough smiles to avoid being a total loss, but it is far from a new holiday classic. It is a well-meaning reminder that sometimes, even with a great cast and a cute dog, you just can't fix a broken heart without a better script.
Recommendation: If you're a dog lover or a Zooey Deschanel superfan, give it a stream on a lazy Sunday, but don't expect it to become a yearly tradition.
 Movie Review: A Christmas Canine Comedy That Stays in the Doghouse){kind=link}
0 Comments